Congressional primary breaks Onondaga County’s record for early voting in a primary – WAER

“In Onondaga County, we seem to be an outlier where more people are voting in early voting and I don’t know what it indicates. I don’t know if it’s going to mean lower turnout for the primary or are people choosing to vote early as part of the convenience of voting early because August is particularly busy with recreational activities,” Czarny said.

https://www.waer.org/2022-08-22/congressional-primary-breaks-the-record-in-onondaga-county-for-early-voting-in-a-primary

The Weekly Wonk: NY Assembly District #127

Welcome to the #weeklywonk. This is my weekly blog about statistics, registration data, and election law on my website, dustinczarny.com. This is a rebrand of my #wonkywednesday and #sundaythoughts columns I have been writing since 2020. In merging these two side projects together I am hoping to be a little more regular in my production. I have also not tied myself to a particular day to release these columns, hoping to release them weekly on the weekend. This way I can have more time to gather the statistics and resources that I want to devote to these articles. This week I return to our General Election registration previews with NY Assembly District 127.

#Ad127 has been represented by Assemblyman Al Stirpe since 2008 with the exception of 2010-2012 when he lost his re-election in the red wave of 2010. The core of this district remains the towns Clay, Cicero, and Manlius.  These are the three largest town in Onondaga County and have been in this district during since at least 2002. They remained during in the new district passed by the Assembly this last year. The towns of Pompey, Tully and Fabius were in the district during the last ten years but are now out. Now in the district this assembly seat goes east into Madison County picking up the Town of Cazenovia. The Assembly district may be altered yet again next cycle as the current Assembly lines are under judicial review.

The new #AD127 has 93,540 voters in it. It is considered lean Democratic district with Democrats making up the plurality of the district at 34%. The GOP is in second at 31%. The Non-enrolled is a close third at 28%. Regionally this district is dominated by the Town of Clay at 44% of the registered voter population. Manlius is at 27% and Cicero at 24%. The town of Cazenovia is just 5%.

For years, this district was seen as a lean red district. The changing nature of the suburbs during the Trump presidency. As the suburbs got bluer so did the district. Between 2012 & 212 the old district saw Democrats gained 5088 voters, the GOP only gained 389 voters, and the non-enrolled gained the most at 5054. The 2022 figures represent the new #AD127. The drop off of voters reflected the overpopulation that happened in the district during the last ten years. Clay, Cicero, and Manlius were some of the fastest growing areas of our country. The result of the redistricting caused Democrats to lose 1,018 voters, GOP to lose 1772 voters, and non-enrolled to lose 1338 voters. This made the district slightly bluer than before.

The Town of Clay dominates the district both in region and its bluer nature has fueled the trend toward Democrat enrollment. We will look at the town of Manlius later this year, but it is not only the second highest Town in population it is now one of the bluer towns and rapidly changing. Cicero remains the only populous town with out a blue enrollment edge with the GOP still having a significant plurality in the town. While the Town of Cazenovia is slightly GOP, the addition of this town with the exclusion of Pompey and Tully does make it a bluer town as it is less populous and less GOP than them.

We have not had elections in the new district so our comparative results will be on the old district. Since there were only slight changes it is reasonable to expect the new district will react similar. It is definitely a swing district reacting race by race. Biden won the old district by 10.28 points in 2020 while GOP Congressman John Kakto won it by 11.76 points. IN the Governor’s race of 2018 GOP candidate Mark Molinaro won the district by 4.66 points. Al Stirpe has easily won his last two reelections in 2018 by 16.03 points and 2020 by 9.13 points. While we can’t tell how the new district will react race by race, NY Redistricting and you did do an analysis on the Presidential performance.  It shows that Biden won the old district by 10.6% and the new district by 12.0%. So, this is a slight swing of 1.4% and it is hard to tell if the district will swing that way in down ballot races.

Next week I will continue my review of the races on the ballot for the General election. Next up I look at the 126th Assembly District the only GOP held state district in Onondaga County. I plan to look at each race on the General election ballot leading up to November. Remember to subscribe to dustinczarny.com to get all election news and content updates.

Democratic legislators sue Onondaga County for gerrymandering – WAER

“PlanScore, a non-profit website by the campaign legal center, another non-profit entity, scored the plan in February of 2020 and said that in 94% of all results, Republicans would lead the county legislature. That is in a county where Democrats have a large plurality of registered voters. In fact, Republicans are the third in Onondaga County,” Czarny said.

https://www.waer.org/2022-08-18/democratic-legislators-sue-onondaga-county-for-gerrymandering

Onondaga County Democrats file formal complaint over new district maps – Spectrum News

“This process was designed at the start to put a partisan gerrymander to ensure a minority rule of Republicans on the county Legislature. And our experts that we are bringing forth in our proceedings will show this,” said Onondaga County Democratic Elections Commissioner Dustin Czarny.

https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/politics/2022/08/18/onondaga-county-democrats-file-formal-complaint-over-new-district-maps

Odd timing, low turnout could be recipe for election surprise in CNY race for Congress – Syracuse.com

“We had about 15% turnout in June, and if I’m a betting person that’s probably where we’ll be for this election,” said Dustin Czarny, Onondaga County’s Democratic elections commissioner.

https://www.syracuse.com/politics/2022/08/odd-timing-low-turnout-could-be-recipe-for-election-surprise-in-cny-race-for-congress.html?fbclid=IwAR3LMogyZ0z1YqdK2HquMiELdgX9k0jwDgqk7PtnKi4S_8DqeEM5csy4mUs

Democratic lawmakers sue Onondaga County, claiming legislative maps are ‘a nullity’ – Syracuse.com

“I’m taking the rare step of joining this lawsuit because I believe in fair districting and I believe that the voters of Onondaga County were not served by the process,’’ Czarny said.

https://www.syracuse.com/news/2022/08/democratic-lawmakers-sue-onondaga-county-claiming-legislative-maps-are-a-nullity.html

Democrats accuse Onondaga County of “racially” gerrymandered district map – CNYCentral.com

“They did not take into account the public comments that were given, they did not take into account the public calls to have a more inclusive and open public hearing schedule over a longer period of time,” according to Dustin Czarny. “They rushed to put their maps in place in effort to beat Governor Hochul from signing the law that guaranteed that fair districting had to happen on the County level.”

https://cnycentral.com/news/local/lawsuit-filed-against-racially-politically-gerrymandered-district-maps

Lawsuit on Challenging Onondaga County map

In August I took part in a Press Conference today with Legislator Chris Ryan and Common Council President Helen Hudson announcing the filing of a legal challenge to the Onondaga County Legislative maps which we allege are a partisan and racial gerrymander in violation of the Onondaga County Charter, the Municipal Home Rule Law, and NY Constitution. Here is the press conference in it’s entirety.

You can help with this effort by donating here: https://secure.actblue.com/donate/ocdcddf

February 2, 2023 Onondaga County finally answers original claim. Awaiting discovery schedule and trial dates.

January 12, 2023 Lawsuit survives motion to dismiss heads to next phase.

Original August 2022 Complaint:

Planscore Evaluation of new Onondaga County Maps:

Articles about Redistricting:

Something went wrong. Please refresh the page and/or try again.

Democrats in Onondaga County file lawsuit over County Legislature’s new voting maps – WSYR 9

“They made the illegal decision to have the county legislature draw their own maps and pass their own maps,” Czarny said. “Which are also illegal.”

“The redistricting commission known as the reapportionment commission took only three weeks from inception to finish, to vote on maps,” he added.

https://www.localsyr.com/news/local-news/democrats-in-onondaga-county-file-lawsuit-over-county-legislatures-new-voting-maps/

Zoom with Czarny: Alissa Italiano for Manlius Town Board

Today I sit down with Alissa Italiano for Manlius Town Board. She is running to fill a vacancy on the Manlius Town Board while also sitting on the board and preparing to run again next year. She is a fine member of the Town of Manlius Board and I hope you enjoy.

Subscribe to dustinczarny.com for all content and election news updates.